Indexing guide
Blocked by robots.txt: how to fix it
A rule in your robots.txt file stops Googlebot from crawling these URLs. Sometimes that is on purpose, sometimes it is a costly mistake.
ReadAlternate page with proper canonical tag: is it a problem?
This status usually means your canonical tags are working. Here is how to spot the few cases where they are not.
If Google Search Console shows alternate page with proper canonical tag for some of your pages, this guide explains what it means and how to fix it, step by step.
Quick answer
Alternate page with proper canonical tag means the page points to another URL with a rel="canonical" tag, and Google agreed and indexed that other URL. Google says there is nothing you need to do. Check it only if a page you want ranking appears here, which means its canonical tag points to the wrong URL.
What does alternate page with proper canonical tag mean?
The Search Console Page indexing report help says this page is an alternate of another page that Google recognises as canonical, the page correctly points to it, and there is nothing to do. It is the healthy partner of duplicate without user-selected canonical, where no canonical was set.
What causes it?
These are the most common causes I see when auditing client sites:
- URL parameters such as ?utm_source= or ?ref= that canonicalise to the clean URL
- Mobile, AMP or print versions pointing to the main page
- Product variants (colour or size) pointing to one main product
- Paginated or filtered category URLs pointing to the main category
- A theme or plugin setting the wrong canonical on real pages
How do you fix it?
First find the affected URLs in Search Console, then work through the steps in order and stop when the issue is solved. The pictures show each stage.
- Filter the report and list the URLs. If they are parameter or variant URLs, leave them
- If an important page is listed, open it and view the source for rel="canonical"
- Fix canonicals that point to the home page or to page 1 of a series by mistake
- Give every real page a self-referencing canonical
- Keep internal links and the sitemap pointing to the canonical URL only
- Use URL Inspection to compare the user-declared and Google-selected canonical
- Request indexing for the fixed page once
Quick reference table
| Search Console status | What it means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Alternate page with proper canonical tag | You set a canonical and Google agreed | Nothing, unless a key page is listed |
| Duplicate without user-selected canonical | No canonical set and Google picked one | Add a canonical tag |
| Duplicate, Google chose different canonical than user | You set one and Google disagreed | Align redirects, links and sitemap |
| Page with redirect | The URL redirects elsewhere | Usually nothing |
Example: a canonical that pointed to page 1
Example
A shop had 40 blog archive pages listed under this status. That was fine. But 12 product categories were listed too, because a theme setting made page 2, 3 and 4 canonicalise to page 1, so products deeper in the list were found slowly. Switching those pages to self-referencing canonicals fixed it without touching the 40 archive URLs.
When is it a bigger problem?
It is a real problem only when pages you want in search are listed. That usually means a template, SEO plugin or migration set the same canonical on many pages. Fix the template once and the whole group recovers. My on-page SEO service includes a canonical check on every template.
Not sure which pages are affected or why? My technical SEO service starts with a free audit, and the free SEO checklist covers the basics.
Frequently asked questions
Is alternate page with proper canonical tag bad?
No. Google says there is nothing you need to do. It shows that your canonical tags are being respected.
Why are so many pages listed?
Parameter, tracking, variant and pagination URLs add up quickly. A large number is normal on shops and blogs.
Should I add noindex to these pages?
No. A canonical tag already handles them. Adding noindex sends mixed signals.
Will these pages show in Google?
Usually not. Google shows the canonical version instead, which is the goal.
How do I check which canonical Google picked?
Use URL Inspection in Search Console. It shows the user-declared canonical and the Google-selected canonical.
Does this status waste crawl budget?
Only a little on most sites. Very large sites can reduce it by cleaning up parameter URLs and internal links.
Sources
Facts checked on 8 October 2026 against these official pages. Read how I check facts in my editorial policy and disclaimer.
Related indexing guides
All guides
Indexing guide
Crawled, currently not indexed: how to fix it
Google visited your page but chose not to add it to the index yet. Here is why, and what to do.
Read
Indexing guide
Discovered, currently not indexed: causes and fixes
Google knows the page exists but has not crawled it yet. Here is how to change that.
ReadWant help with your SEO?
Send your website and I will reply with a free audit.